From a Rotator Cuff Tear to Bench Pressing and Pickleball Again

By Published On: November 17, 2026

This client whose experience we’re sharing in this case study, has never been injured deeply before. He spent his younger years bouncing back from everything without a second thought but a rotator cuff tear changed that. It was his first real injury, and it hit him hard. He used to go to the gym and bench press regularly. Suddenly he couldn’t, and that was really frustrating.

Burning Pain Kept Him Awake

The shoulder pain was bad when he first came to us. It brought a burning pain that woke him up at night. Reaching into the glove box or the center console for his garage door opener hurt. Washing the dishes or washing his car, with that circular “wax on, wax off” motion, bothered his shoulder too. Even lifting his arms was painful, and he’d end up compensating with his trapezius.

He was much better than when he started at the end of his first 12 weeks. Still, he wasn’t all the way there. He had some trouble with range of motion and some pain left over and bench pressing still felt very unstable, and his right shoulder felt weak.

Physical therapy for shoulder pain was never meant to last forever. It was a tool to get him back to a normal, healthy lifestyle. He’d already come a long way, and if he could get a little more, why not? So he moved on to our Bulletproof phase.

The Turning Point

The first 12 weeks was very targeted with the right exercises. It was mostly banded exercises and homework with a kettlebell or a bench and all of them were focused on his shoulder and rotator cuff. The Bulletproof phase brought in compound exercises, bigger movements, and more functional work to get him back into proper training.

Halfway through, he had a small flare-up which he thinks happened because he overdid the sleeper stretch, and it bothered him for a couple of days. Then things clicked. One day he did his exercises, including D2 flexion, then did a dumbbell bench press at a 45-degree angle at the gym, and played pickleball that night. He was sure he’d pay for it the next day, because that’s what always used to happen. Instead, he felt great.

He believes the lateral raise movement played a part in his original injury. Also, he avoided it for the first several weeks while the other muscles got stronger. Then it came back in at the right time through D2 flexion, ER presses, the archer band pull, the subscap punch, and an external rotation exercise. He calls these some of the most helpful rotator cuff exercises in his program.

Results

  • Burning pain that woke him at night is gone
  • Can reach into the glove box and center console without pain
  • Washing dishes and washing his car no longer bother him
  • Lifting his arms no longer causes pain or compensation
  • Bench pressing feels stronger and more comfortable
  • Can train, then play pickleball, and feel great the next day

What Changed And Why It Worked?

The Bulletproof phase gave him more strength and stability. It also gave him confidence and range of motion so that he could get back into a normal workout routine.

He says that without it, he would have stayed stuck. Additionally, he wouldn’t have felt comfortable doing many of the movements he does now. Before, the soreness after a workout made him want to skip the gym altogether. That’s no longer the case, and it’s one of the biggest wins of his rotator cuff tear recovery.

What He’d Tell Someone

His advice – do it, and don’t hesitate. You’ve already come this far, so don’t give up now. Everyone’s different, but he says it can’t hurt and can only help, and you’ll be glad you did.

Knowing what he knows now, he would make the same decision. The second phase gave him the knowledge and tools to keep going on his own, which is exactly what a rotator cuff tear recovery should give you.

You deserve a pain-free life.

If you feel like you’ve tried everything – massage, acupuncture, traditional physical therapy – and you’re still in pain, it’s time to try something different. Our personalized movement-based rehab bulletproofs your shoulder for good.

About the Author: Dr. Joey Seyforth

Dr. Joey Seyforth, DPT, is a physical therapist who specializes in helping people overcome shoulder pain by blending sports medicine, strength training, and movement science. Through his Targeted Comeback Process, he teaches clients how to restore mobility, build resilience, and achieve long-term shoulder health without relying on injections, surgeries, or cookie-cutter rehab.